Contact Us
  • Comment

Jacksonville sheriff on arrest of brother: 'He's being dealt with like anybody else'

Posted: January 23, 2014 - 10:23am  |  Updated: January 23, 2014 - 1:48pm
Hubert C. Rutherford
Hubert C. Rutherford

Jacksonville Sheriff John Rutherford’s brother was in Duval County jail Thursday, after his Jan. 12 arrest on domestic-violence and child-abuse charges, court records show.

Bail for Hubert C. Rutherford, 49, was set at $80,000 and he awaits a Feb. 4 court date.

The court records show that Hubert Rutherford was arrested at his home on Mother Goose Road, after police talked to a 15-year-old female who had a red, hand-shaped mark across her face and scratches. The report quotes the girl as saying Rutherford had come home drunk, encountered the 15-year-old with her 18-year-old boyfriend and a stray dog, argued over the dog and became violent.

The teens, described in the court records as victims, told police of a fist fight that also involved Rutherford’s live-in girlfriend, Kari Jean Reynolds, 48, who also was arrested.

The teens told officers that when they left the home, Rutherford chased after them, swinging something described variously as a broomstick or a golf club.

The records say Rutherford had blood around his mouth and nose after the confrontation and Reynolds also suffered wounds. The records describe Rutherford as “very intoxicated” and said he “was belligerent and continually yelled profanities.” It said he declined to talk with police before being arrested.

Reynolds was too intoxicated to describe the sequence of events, police said, but after police arrived she twice threatened to kill the girl.

Rutherford was charged with felony domestic battery, child abuse, aggravated assault, and misdemeanor battery.

Reynolds also was arrested on charges of child abuse and misdemeanor battery. She was released from jail Jan. 16.

The 15-year-old was released into the custody of her mother, records show.

Sheriff Rutherford told the Times-Union Thursday that police contacted him after the arrest to make him aware of the incident and he wasn’t asked, and didn’t attempt, to get involved.

“They alerted me that he had been arrested and I said to handle him like anybody else,” Rutherford said. “They thought I would need to know that they were following protocol. He’s being dealt with like anybody else. They put him in jail and he’s going through the process like anybody else.”

Lindsay Van-Zant, development specialist with Hubbard House, a Jacksonville woman’s shelter for domestic violence victims, said no one at the agency could talk about the pending case against Hubert Rutherford. Sheriff Rutherford has been recognized repeatedly for his support of Hubbard House and other causes for victims of domestic violence.

“Whenever police are called, they are the ones who make the judgment call,” Van-Zant said about arrest in domestic-violence incidents. “They are trained to make that assessment.”

Sheriff Rutherford acknowledged that it wasn’t his brother’s first arrest, but declined to elaborate or talk further about his brother.

Court and police records show that Hubert Rutherford was charged in 2011 with driving with a suspended driver’s license, for which he pleaded no contest and received a fine. Court records show he still owes money in the case and a collection agency has been contacted.

Records also show that Hubert Rutherford pled no contest in 2009 to a domestic-violence charge involving allegations that he and a woman at the Mother Goose Road address were involved in a fight that led police to arrest both people. He pleaded no contest to fighting and received a fine.

Hubert Rutherford was convicted in 1995 of boating while under the influence and resisting police without violence, for which he was ordered to DUI classes, records show. He also had a handful of criminal-traffic charges, including fleeing and attempting to elude police and DUI, dating to 1984, records show.

Jim Schoettler: (904) 359-4385

Comments (10)

ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
Howard 01/23/14 - 10:49 pm
Premium Member

." He’s being dealt with like

." He’s being dealt with like anybody else. They put him in jail and he’s going through the process like anybody else.”

So, Angela Corey is overcharging him and hopes to put him in jail for the rest of his life.

jnfsu 01/23/14 - 05:09 pm
Premium Member

No one insinuated that he

No one insinuated that he sometimes voids tickets - he admitted that he does, and that he didn't/doesn't follow proper procedures for doing so. It's fact. As far as I know, Sheriff Rutherford has been totally, totally honest about his wrongdoing(s), though I don't think he's actually apologized for it - and he should.

That said, I don't think anyone has said that Sheriff Rutherford's brother's wrongdoings are a reflection of the sheriff's honesty or dishonesty.

Michael Hallett
Michael Hallett 01/23/14 - 04:20 pm

One comes to expect these

One comes to expect these comments to be vicious. But these and some over the past many days are very unfair. I've had the opportunity to work with John Rutherford in creating Pretrial Services Unit at JSO and other projects. Like most cops, he believes we can police our way out of poverty; I think it's clear we can't. We disagree. But he is a totally, totally honest person. The insinuations of the past many days are way off base. He got elected multiple times for a reason.

johnctaughtme 01/23/14 - 02:33 pm
Premium Member

I have to have a little

I have to have a little empathy here. All of us have families, and too frequently everybody in those families does not live "at the foot of The Cross". Clearly, the guy has problems, and regular readers and people with families know that he is hardly alone in that.

Somewhere here there ought to be a little room for prayers for this guy and his family, including the Sheriff.

lilrio 01/23/14 - 02:27 pm
Premium Member

I have to say the sheriff did

I have to say the sheriff did the right thing and stayed out of it with the arrest of his brother avoiding a conflict of interest and let his department follow protocol. Let's see how the next step pans out with charges & the SAO.

Back to Top

Sign up for's morning newsletter and get top stories each morning in your inbox.